• My series on making a Newtonian telescope
  • How Leon Foucault Made Telescopes

Guy's Math & Astro Blog

Guy's Math & Astro Blog

Category Archives: History

Religions based on … well … myths, or alternative facts. Or lies.

14 Friday Apr 2017

Posted by gfbrandenburg in History, nature, science

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

buddha, christ, evidence, gods, jesus, krishna, lies, mohammed, prophecy, religion

Every single religion that I can think of seems to be based on totally unreliable witnesses and stories that are mis-remembered (at best) or deliberately distorted.

Judaism just celebrated one of its most important rituals, the Passover seder, in which I have participated about six times. If you’ve forgotten, the story is supposedly recorded in the Old Testament (or Tanakh) and the event celebrates the freeing of a large group of Hebrew people from Egypt. They then wandered the Sinai desert (a very, very hot and dry place – I lived next to it for about 9 months).

The problem is, there is absolutely nothing in the historical record that corroborates any of this story. The Egyptians kept a lot of records, and much of it is still readable — no mention of any such tribe fleeing, no first-borns murdered, no special heavenly plagues, yadda, yadda. No archaeological evidence whatsoever of any tribe of Hebrews wandering in the Sinai desert for any such expedition.

(Stuff like that gets preserved there! In fact, at the famous fort and palace known as Masada, near the Dead Sea, you can clearly see the streets and walls of the camp built by the legions of the Roman Army that besieged and eventually captured the fort, from roughly 2000 years ago! Now THAT incident and war is definitely mentioned — in Josephus, among other places…)

That story of Abraham getting ready to slit his son’s throat and god providing a lamb instead? Really? Inscribed tablets from Mount Sinai – really? How do we know any of this? We don’t. And in any case, if God tells you to commit genocide (it’s spelled out in Genesis / BeReshit), is that a wonderful thing? I don’t think so.

If we get to Jesus, well, again, the evidence that he produced any miracles or was somehow resurrected and became one with God (or didn’t) is pretty darned thin. Today is supposedly the day that he got crucified (the Romans were NOT nice people!!!), which was a shame. The Romans killed and tortured and enslaved a LOT of people. I’m not so sure that they should be held in such high esteem…

But I can think of many ways that a body can be taken out of a tomb, and none of them involve miracles or angels. Then, if you read all of the various Gospels, canonical or not, you realize that their outlooks and details are all profoundly at odds with each other.

If you come to Mohammed, I can think of many ways that somebody could appear to be possessed and to recite various lines of poetry (see Mormons, below) — although that would certainly explain why he would have prophecies that justified what he wanted to do (such as marry little girls) or needed to be amended (see Satanic Verses…)

Now both Jesus and Mohammed said some stuff about equality and supporting the poor, nonetheless the leaders of both religions (Popes, Kings, Emperors, Califs and so on) ended up being wealthy beyond anybody’s dreams, while the majority of people lived in pretty base poverty….

If you go back to the founding of Buddhism, what does that mean that someone is ‘enlightened’? How do we know if someone is in fact in that state? Is it even a good thing to attempt to achieve it? It seems to me that it’s more worth while to try to be good to other people (without endangering your own welfare unless absolutely necessary) and to try to leave the entire planet (and solar system) a better place for your descendants — by not driving species to extinction, not raising the global temperature if at all possible, and by helping so many billions of our kin to avoid lives of infernal poverty and oppression.

Hinduism seems to blame the poor and lowest classes for having been wicked people in a past life, and therefore should be not permitted equality with the upper castes. Sounds great if you are a Brahmin, but what an oppressive religion, really! And how can anybody with an ounce of skepticism believe any of those stories?

Going back to 2000+ years ago — All those stories that the Romans, the Greeksm the Babylonians, Persians and Egyptians made up about their gods — are you serious? They actually believed that? Well, you may as well believe in the Tooth Fairy or the Easter Bunny or the Flying Spaghetti Monster!

Oh, can’t leave out the Mormons. Golden plates buried in upstate New York but only viewable and translatable by someone talking through his hat, writing pseudo-king-James-English and talking about lots of animals and plants and metals that supposedly were used by warring tribes of American Indians — and nobody has ever found figs, wheat, camels, sheep, goats, or horses, or the use of iron or wheeled vehicles of any sort anywhere in the Americas for the entire period of say 500 BC to 1491. So that’s all a lie, too.

Sorry if I offend you, but while I know I’m not perfect (far from it) I don’t need fairy tales to try to be a better human being. I prefer to know things that are true and verifiable. And I really don’t like it when people try to kill each other to support ideas that are really just hoaxes.

 

How Britain Became an Island

06 Thursday Apr 2017

Posted by gfbrandenburg in History, science

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Britain, Calais, Cap Gris-Nez, Chalk, cliffs, Dover, England, Island

Interesting report with pretty geological maps indicate that the Island we call Britain got cut off from what we know as France and Belgium by a catastrophic waterfall and flood that broke through what we now call the Straits of Dover as the ice that covered Northern Europe was beginning to melt, and sea levels were much lower than today.

Gupta_NCOMMS-16-16909A_Fig2_rev2

Here is the link. 

By the way, if the weather is fairly clear, it’s easy to see the famous White Cliffs of Dover from the French side (for example, at Cap Gris-Nez).

The Mathematics of George Washington

24 Friday Feb 2017

Posted by gfbrandenburg in History, Math, Uncategorized

≈ 2 Comments

Tags

George Washington, History, Math, surveying

I recently learned some things about how the young George Washington did math, including surveying. Mathematician and historian V. Frederick  Rickey gave a talk 2 nights ago at the Mathematical Association of America here in DC, based on his study of GW’s “cypher books”, and I’d like to share a few things I learned.

(1) The young George appears to have used no trigonometry at all when finding areas of plots of land that he surveyed. Instead, he would ‘plat’ it very carefully, on paper, making an accurate scale drawing with the correct angles and lengths, and then would divide it up into triangles on the paper. To find the areas of those triangles, he would use some sort of a right-angle device, found and drew the altitude, and then multiplied half the base times the height (or altitude). No law of cosines or sines as we teach students today.

(2) He was given formulas for the volumes of spheroids and barrels, apparently without any derivation or justification that they were correct, to hold so many gallons of wine or of beer. (You probably wouldn’t guess that you had to leave extra room for the ‘head’ on the beer.) Rickey has not found the original source for those formulas, but using calculus and the identity pi = 22/7, he showed that they were absolutely correct.

(3) GW was a very early adopter of decimals in America.

(4 ) This last one puzzled me quite a bit. It’s supposed to be a protractor, but it only gives approximations to those angles. The results are within 1 degree, which I guess might be OK for some uses. I used the law of cosines to convince myself that they were almost all a little off. Here’s an accurate diagram, with angle measurements, that I made with Geometer’s Sketchpad.

His method was to lay out on paper a segment 60 units long (OB) and then to construct a sixth-of-a-circle with center B, passing through O and G (in green). Then he drew five more arcs, each with its center at O, going through the poitns marked as 10, 20, 30, 40, and 50 units from O. The claim is then that angle ABO would be 10 degrees. It’s not. It’s only 9.56 degrees.

george-washingtons-protractor

A Talk at AHSP on Telescope Making

16 Friday Sep 2016

Posted by gfbrandenburg in astronomy, History, Telescope Making

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

AHSP, Almost Heaven Star Party, Charles Messier, Messier Objects, NOVAC, Spruce Knob, West Virginia

Two weeks ago was the Almost Heaven Star Party on the slopes of Spruce Knob, West Virginia, sponsored and organized by the Northern Virginia Astronomy Club (NOVAC). The weather was wonderful, and we could see the Milky Way and lots of Messier objects with our naked eyes, every single night for four nights. This is by far the longest stretch of good weather I’ve ever experienced up there at The Mountain Institute.

(Friday and Saturday, it was only clear for a few hours, but Sunday and Monday nights were clear all night, AND there was NO DEW to speak of!! Wow!!)

During the daytime, there were lots of talks and also activities and expeditions such as hiking, spelunking, visiting the National Radio Astronomy Observatory at Green Bank, canoeing, and Phun With Physics and arts & crafts for kids. I particularly enjoyed the talks on Russell Porter (the founder of amateur telescope making in the US and one of the major designers of the 200-inch telescope at Palomar), LIGO (detection of gravity waves), and Rod Molisse’s talk on 50 years of mostly-commercial telescopes as seen in the pages of various astronomy regime.

I was one of the speakers and gave a little talk on telescope-making. If you care to sit through it, you can find it along with all of the other talks (many of which I missed for various reasons) at this web-page.

I brought my home-made 12.5″ Dob-Newt [shown to the left in the picture below] and added about a dozen items to my formal list of Messier objects. (I had already seen all 100+ objects, but hadn’t recorded enough details on them to be able to earn one of the ‘merit badge’ pins from the Astronomical League, so I’m going through the list again

.img_0198

(If you didn’t know: Charles Messier loved hunting comets about 220 years ago, with what we would consider today to be a fairly small (4″ diameter) refractor that he used from downtown Paris, not far from where I lived back in 1959. Comets look like fuzzy patches in the sky, and so do galaxies, star clusters, and illuminated clouds of gas, all of which are MUCH farther away and MUCH larger. Comets are part of our own solar system, and move noticeably from one night to the next against the apparently fixed background of stars. Messier is credited with discovering 13 comets. But when he discovered a fuzzy item in the sky that did NOT move, he would record its location and its appearance, so as to avoid looking at it again. He published and updated this list a few times before he died, 199 years ago. Nowadays, his list of things-to-be-avoided are some of the most amazing and beautiful things you can see in the night sky. I’ve tried imaging a few of them, but am very, very far from being proficient at it. I attach my best one so far, of something called the Dumbbell Nebula. No, it’s not named after me. And thanks to Mike Laugherty for helping with the color balance!)

dumbbell-processed-november-1-2015

Movie about Ramanujan

19 Thursday May 2016

Posted by gfbrandenburg in History, Math

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

ramanujan

I recommend going to see ‘The Man Who Knew Infinity’, about the famous Indian mathematician Srinivasa Ramanujan, whose originality astonished the greatest mathematicians of his day, G H Hardy and Littlewood.

It’s a historical romance rather than a documentary, so there are parts that are completely made up — like German Zeppelins bombing Cambridge University during World War 1, and off-duty British soldiers beating up Ramanujan for being a foreign draft dodger. A weird aspect is that the actors and directors don’t seem to be on the same page about the correct pronunciation of Ramanujan’s name. They mostly put the accent on the third syllable, where as far as I can tell it should be more like ruh – MAHN – uh – jahn.

However, there was such a bombing near-by during the war, and the British army did have temporary hospitals for wounded soldiers during that war, and Ramanujan did contract tuberculosis and die at the sadly early age of 32, after he had gone back home. And apparently his mother had indeed been intercepting letters to and from his wife, so they were completely cut off from each other, as the movie states.

And of course, they can’t really explain much of the mathematics – heck, I can’t understand much of anything that Ramanujan did! Even his simplest formulas are way, way over my head! Dramatizing partitions of a number was probably a wise move, since it’s one of the few things that an ordinary person might understand.

 

 

 

 

On Making an Artificial Star for an Indoor Star Tester

04 Sunday Jan 2015

Posted by gfbrandenburg in History, Telescope Making

≈ 2 Comments

Tags

artificial star, ATM, CCCC, couder, foucault, Hubble, NCA, Ronchi, star testing, Telescope

I help run the amateur telescope-making workshop at the Chevy Chase Community Center in Washington, DC, sponsored and under the auspices of the National Capital Astronomers. Both the NCA and its ATM group have been on-going since the 1930’s, well before I was born. In our ATM group, have the somewhat esoteric thrill of manufacturing incredibly accurate scientific devices (telescopes), from scratch, with not much more than our bare hands and a few tools. And then we go and use them to observe the incredible universe we come from.

Since these telescope mirrors are required to be insanely accurate, we need extremely high-precision ways of testing them. However, we don’t have the tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars needed to purchase something like a professional Zygo Interferometer, so we use much cheaper ways of testing our mirror surfaces.

Some of those methods are associated with the names Foucault, Couder, Bath, Ronchi, Ross, Everest, and Mobsby, or are described with words like “knife-edge”, “double-pass” and “wire”. They all require some relatively simple apparatus and skill and practice in measurement and observation.

We are of the opinion that no one single test should be trusted: it’s easy to make some sort of error. (I’ve made plenty.) You may perhaps recall the disaster that happened when the Hubble Space Telescope mirror passed one test with flying colors, and other tests that weren’t so good were ignored. When the HST finally flew in orbit, it was discovered that the mirror was seriously messed up: the test that was trusted was flawed, so the mirror was also flawed.

We don’t want to do that. So, at a minimum, we do the Ronchi and Foucault/Couder knife-edge tests before we say that a mirror is ready to coat.

But the ultimate test of an entire telescope is the star test.

In principle, all you need for that is a steady star, your telescope, a short-focal-length eyepiece, and a copy of Richard Suiter’s book on star-testing optical telescopes.

Unfortunately, around here, it’s often cloudy at night, and if it’s clear, it might be windy, and around the CCCC building there are lots of lights — all of which make star-testing a scope on the two evenings a week that we are open, virtually impossible. We aren’t open in the daytime, and even if we were, I don’t see any ceramic insulators on any telephone poles that are both small enough and far enough away to use as artificial stars in the manner that Suiter describes. (There are a few radio towers visible, but I doubt that their owners would let us climb up one of them and hang up a Christmas tree ornament near the top!)

So, that means we need to make an artificial star.

I’ve been reading a few websites written by folks who have done just that, and it seems to be a bit easier than I thought. The key is to get a source of light that acts like a star at astronomical distances — but close enough that we can fit it inside the basement of the CCCC, probably not in the woodshop where we make the scopes, but more likely out in the hallway or in the large activity room next door, both of which are about 40 or 50 feet long.

So here are my preliminary calculations.

First off, it appears that the resolving power of a telescope equals the wavelength being used, divided by the diameter of the objective lens or mirror, both expressed in the same units. The result is in radians, which you can then turn into degrees, arc-minutes, arc-seconds, or whatever you like, but it’s perhaps easier to leave in radians. In any case, the larger the diameter, the tinier the angle that your telescope can resolve if it’s working properly.

I am going to use a 16-inch mirror diameter, or about 0.4 meters, as an example, and I will use green light at about 560 nanometers (560 x 10^-9 m) because that’s pretty close to the green mercury line we have in our monochromatic light box. I then get that the resolution is 1.4×10^-6 radians.

resolution of lens or mirror

(We can convert that into arc-seconds by multiply that by 180 degrees per PI radians  and by 60 arc-minutes per degree  and by 60 arc-seconds per arc-minute; we then get about 0.289 arc-seconds. If we were to use an 8-inch mirror, the resolution would be half as good, meaning the object would need to be twice as big to be resolved, or about 0.578 arc-seconds.)

resolution in arc seconds

I read that one can make an artificial star by using an ordinary eyepiece and a small illuminated hole that is put some distance away from the eyepiece. The entire setup is aimed at the telescope, and then you have an artificial star. Here is the general idea:

artificial star setup

Supposedly, the equations go as follows, with all of the dimensions in the same units. I think I will use millimeters.

Star Size of artificial rigWe want to make it so that the size of the artificial star will be small enough to be below the limit of resolution of any telescope we are making. I am pretty sure that we can set things up so that there is 40 feet (13 meters) between our telescope rig and the table or tripod on which we sill set up this artificial star.

I also know that I can find an eyepiece with a focal length of 12 mm that I’m willing to use for this purpose, and I also purchased some tiny little holes from “Hubble Optics” that are of the following sizes: 50, 100, 150, 200, and 250 microns, or millionths of a meter. Those holes are TINY!!! So that takes care of H and F. I still need to figure out what SS should be.

A few lines ago, I found that for a 16-inch telescope, I need a resolution of about 1.4×10^-6 radians. The nice thing about radians is that if you want to find the length of the arc at a certain radius, you don’t need to do any conversions at all: the length of the arc is simply the angle (expressed in radians) times the length of the radius, as shown here:

angle arc radius

c=theta times Radius

So if our artificial star is going to be 13 meters away, and we know that the largest angle allowed is roughly 1.4×10^-6 radians, I just multiply and I get 1.82×10^-5 meters, or 1.82 x 10^-2 millimeters, or 18.2 microns.

Which means that I already have holes that are NOT small enough: the 150-micron holes are about 10 times too big at a distance of 13 meters, so my premature rejoicing of a few minutes ago, was, in fact, wrong.  So, when I make the artificial star gizmo, I’ll need to figure out how to make the ‘star size’ to be roughly one-tenth the size of the holes in the Hubble Optics micro-hole flashlight.

Or, if I rearrange the equation with the L, H, F and SS, I get that L = H * F / SS. The only unknown is L, the distance between the hole and the eyepiece/lens. For H, I have several choices (50, 100, 150, 200 and 250 microns), SS is now known to be 18 microns or so (36 if I want to test an 8-incher), and I plan on using a 12.5 mm eyepiece. If I plug in the 150 micron hole, then I get that L needs to be about 104 millimeters, or only about 4 inches. Note that the longer L is, the smaller the artificial star becomes. Also, if I replace the 12.5 mm eyepiece with a shorter one, then the artificial star will become smaller; similarly, the smaller the Hubble Optics hole, the smaller the artificial star. This all sounds quite doable indeed.

Build Your Telescope Tube and Mount

16 Tuesday Dec 2014

Posted by gfbrandenburg in History, Telescope Making

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

alt-az, company 7, equatorial, hands-on-optics, plywood, teflon

7. Build the scope

A. There are many, many books and articles and websites devoted to the many, many ways of building your telescope tube and mount. We have quite a few of these books in our library, and you should definitely study them! In addition, public star parties put on by NOVAC, NCA and other local clubs often have home-made telescopes on the field, and you can ask the makers of those scopes how they did it. Fortunately for us, John Dobson came up with an excellent way of making inexpensive, easy-to-build and easy-to-use telescopes of the Newtonian model, even if he was a nut-case. Willmann-Bell publishes quite a few such books.

B. I strongly recommend an alt-az telescope mount for visual use, rather than an equatorial mount on a pier made of plumbing parts, as people used to make in the 1940s through the 1990s. (As noted earlier, if you want to do astrophotography, you will need a much more complicated and much more expensive mount that tracks the stars precisely. Building such a mount yourself is exceedingly difficult and requires precision machining and electronics!) Most important: plan to make a telescope that is easy to use and not too complicated to build! Using slight modifications of existing plans is much easier than trying something completely novel in design. If you strive for originality, you can be sure that you will need to modify and re-build parts of your invention, perhaps several times, because of problems that you didn’t consider or notice originally. (Think about what a nightmare it would be to drive a Model-T Ford automobile, the first real mass-production car, with all of its nutty and dangerous defects, compared to the comfortable and safe and reliable car that people drive today!)

C. I have a set of plans for a simple 6” Dob on this very blog. (Click for link)

D. At the CCCC, we also have a fairly decent set of hand and power tools for working with wood and metal, so you can make the rest of the telescope here if you like. Be careful, and follow safety directions!

E. We even have a wonderful assortment of ‘oops’ paints from hardware and paint stores, if you don’t mind the ghastly colors.

F. You will need at least half of a sheet of 4’ by 8’ plywood for the scope. The plywood can be any type you like, but don’t get a sheet that is warped or wet or too thin. Nice plywood like Appleply or Baltic Birch can be expensive, but it is strong and looks quite beautiful when varnished. Three-quarter inch thickness is standard, but it’s generally sold as a weird number like 23/32”.

G. You will also need the following commercially available items, some of which we usually have on hand, marked by “UOH”.

  1. Diagonal secondary flat elliptical mirror (we have a few)
  2. Secondary mirror holder
  3. Spider
  4. Focuser
  5. Eyepieces
  6. Finder scope(s) (I recommend a 1-power finder like a Telrad or a Red Dot finder, as well as another finder scope that magnifies about 5 to 10 times)
  7. Possibly a Barlow
  8. A few pieces of Teflon UOH
  9. A few square feet of Formica or the equivalent UOH
  10. Miscellaneous screws, nuts, bolts, screws, glue UOH
  11. Guidance UOH
  12. Paint UOH
  13. Random wood scraps, including a short 2-by-4 UOH
  14. For the mirror holder, you need: Three compression springs; 3 flat-headed machine screws; 9 washers; 3 wingnuts; and a small fresh tube of pure-silicone caulk or aquarium cement

H. We are very fortunate to have a local specialty store that sells telescopes and accessories to the public, called Company 7 . It’s located near Laurel, MD and has an amazing display of rare telescopes. Please shop there! (In other words, don’t talk their ears off getting their advice, and then order an item online because it’s a few dollars cheaper!)

(Link forward to the next section ==>)

(<==Link back to the previous section)

Figuring (parabolizing) Your Mirror

16 Tuesday Dec 2014

Posted by gfbrandenburg in History, Telescope Making

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

couder, foucault, parabolization, testing

5. Figuring and Testing

 A. Polishing pads do a great job of polishing out the pits, but they tend to leave a rough surface that is not a true paraboloid or even a section of a sphere, unless you are very, very lucky. Most folks will switch to a pitch lap for the figuring process, which involves removing sub-microscopic amounts of glass from various zones on your mirror, in order first to make it into a section of a sphere, and then into the bottom of a paraboloid – the only geometric figure that will reflect all of the rays that come from distant stars onto a single focal point. Many treatises have been written about figuring, and I’m not going to add to that list. “Understanding Foucault” by David Harbour gives an excellent explanation of the figuring process, as does Mel Bartels here. However, here are some of the basics:

B. You will need a pitch lap, made either of Gugolz or Acculap or Tempered Burgundy pitch. The first two are synthetic products whose composition is probably secret; the third one is made from the sap of coniferous trees. I’m not going to describe the process of making a pitch lap here, but I combine some of the methods of Carl Zambuto and John Dobson when I make a new one; you can watch it as we do it for you. It’s much less work if you can use a pitch lap that was made by or for someone else who has finished their own project. Sometimes a previously-used pitch lap will have sat around too long and might need to be scraped off and remelted. We generally use roughly square facets, which allow the pitch to flow better and conform itself to your mirror. Without the facets, any high points on the lap have a hard time being lowered. We also tend to use netting or a single-edge razor blade to make minifacets, which further help the lap to conform to the mirror.

C. Pitch is weird stuff. When it’s warm, it flows and it’s very sticky. When it’s cold, it is fairly hard, and you can shatter it with a hammer. If you leave a pencil or a coin on a pitch lap overnight, the next day you can see all of the details of the pencil or coin reproduced perfectly in the pitch. We want the lap to conform itself to your mirror. Then we use the pitch lap to remove all of the irregularities that were left by the polishing pads. So, we warm up the pitch lap to soften it a bit (using a heat lamp or hot water), spread Cerox or rouge onto your mirror, and then press the two together briefly but firmly. We often use some netting to create micro-facets, which help the pitch conform to your mirror even more.

D. The figuring stage can severely try your patience, especially if the tests show a surface that looks weird. But relax! If you persevere and don’t drop the mirror on the ground, success is guaranteed, since it’s just a matter of removing the correct millionth of an inch or two (much less than a micrometer) of glass from the correct zonal ring to achieve near-perfection. One needs to make sure that the lap actually conforms to the mirror; bad contact between the two can cause trouble, and so can a pitch lap that is too hard, too soft, or too thin. All of those are fairly easily fixed, with remarkable results. And we are here to help.

E. One major problem that can affect mirrors is a Turned-Down Edge (TDE). Opinions vary on what causes this dreaded condition, but the evidence suggests to me that TDE appears when the lap is exactly the same size, or slightly smaller, than the mirror itself. To avoid a TDE, do not chip off the parts of the pitch lap that ‘mushroom’ out past the edge. Let them stay there.

F. You will be instructed in a specific set of strokes which will first make your mirror into a sphere. Then, you will be instructed in a different set of strokes that will make your mirror into a good approximation of a perfect paraboloid. Texereau, LeCleire, and many other books describe those strokes. So did Leon Foucault in his 1859 article, which you can find on this blog/website. In our workshop, we will test your mirror frequently with a combination of tests, many of them invented by Foucault but later modified.

G. A very fast qualitative test is the Ronchi test, which you can look up. It gives you almost instant feedback on the presence or absence of bad features like turned-down edge (TDE), zonal defects (high or low rings), astigmatism (lack of symmetry), roughness, and so on. It will tell you whether your mirror is a sphere or not – if the Ronchi lines are perfectly straight, then you have a sphere. If they are not straight, then the test can tell us if your mirror is on the way towards being an ellipsoid with the long axis perpendicular to the mirror (or parallel to it), or a hyperboloid, or your goal, a paraboloid. There are several computer programs that provide simulations of what a perfect mirror should look like under the Ronchi test, but I’ve found you can’t always trust those simulations. RonWin is one such program, and Mel Bartels has another on one of his web pages.

H. A more time-consuming test that I find is necessary is the Foucault test as modified by Andre Couder, also known as the numerical knife-edge test with zones. If the Ronchigram looks good, and the numbers in the knife-edge zonal test are also within acceptable limits, then the mirror is done. A slight modification of this test is known as the Wire Test, which works well on fast mirrors. David Harbour’s article does an excellent job of explaining this test. One can use a pinstick method for marking the zones, or one could write directly on the mirror with a Sharpie, but we use a version that uses cardboard masks with holes cut out at carefully-measured zones.

I. We have tried a number of other tests, such as the double-pass autocollimation test, the Mobsby Null test, and the Bath Interferometer test, and have had difficulties getting good results with them. Therefore, we are continuing to use the Ronchi and Knife-Edge Zonal tests.

J. However, the best test of any mirror is the Star Test, which is the subject of an entire book by Richard Suiter. Some do this in the daylight, using sunlight reflected from very distant insulators on electrical poles. Most do it at night, but it requires steady air (‘good seeing’) and a clear sky as well. The Star Test is much easier to perform if the mirror is already aluminized and in a working telescope, which brings us to….

(Link forward to next section==>)

(<==Link back to previous section)

Rough Grinding of a Telescope Mirror

15 Monday Dec 2014

Posted by gfbrandenburg in History, Telescope Making

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Hogging, Rough Grinding

(Part two of my description of the essential steps in making a telescope)

essential atm steps calculate sagitta

2. Hogging Out means making your mirror blank have roughly the proper concave shape for the focal length or f-ratio that you want. There are many articles and web pages on this, which you really should look at!

 A. The math is important: you want your mirror to be a parabola, and the equation for the depth (or sagitta) that you must grind into the glass isn’t too difficult. First of all, “f-ratio” means the ratio between the focal length and the diameter of the primary mirror. So if you plan on making an 8” diameter mirror with a 40-inch focal length, 40” divided by 8” gives you an f-ratio of 5. With no units. If you wanted a 10” diameter mirror with the exact same focal length, we would call that f/4. For the sagitta (depth of curve) required, it’s easiest to use the formula for a parabola facing upwards with its vertex at the origin, namely,  . and you will need to do a little math[1]. Here’s a diagram that I hope will help:  It is supposed to show a mirror (blue) with an insanely short focal length of 7.03 inches and a diameter of 10 inches. The sagitta is the depth at the center of the curve, or length CB, which will be the same as DE and GF. Using the formula   , and plugging in 5 for x and 7.03 for F, we get that y (the sagitta) would be about 0.889 inches, a bit more than 7/8” of an inch of glass to remove. And that’s what we see in the diagram, too, if you look carefully. For a more realistic example, let’s suppose we wanted to make a ten-inch mirror with a focal length of 60 inches (which means that the scope would be about 5 feet long, or roughly 1.5 meters). In that case, we would get a sagitta of about 0.104”, a bit more than a tenth of an inch. You will need some way of measuring the sagitta. We use some spherometers that we fabricated from bits of metal and various dial indicators. Some people use a collection of automobile mechanic’s feeler gauges and a straightedge that goes across the entire diameter. Note that a spherometer will typically NOT measure the entire diameter of your mirror, so you need to account for that smaller diameter. You should calculate and record what your numerical goal is for your chosen method of measurement. However: one nice thing about Newtonian reflectors is that the exact focal length isn’t very important – unlike the other telescope designs, where any deviation from the designed model will cause the project to fail catastrophically. A 6” f/8 scope will work just as well as a 6” f/8.15 scope or a 6” f/7.7 scope; the only difference will be that the first scope tube will be about 48 inches long, the second one closer to 49 inches and the last one closer to 46 inches long.

 B, To grind the mirror, we use relatively coarse grit (silicon carbide, which is not toxic at all) mixed with ordinary tap water. The water acts as a lubricant and also to keep down the glass dust – silica dust causes very serious lung problems if it’s dry. So we keep it wet. We begin with either 50, 60, or 80 grit, depending on the size of the mirror. We put the tool (another cylindrical piece of glass or ceramic, or else something we cast from dental plaster and hard ceramic tiles) on many thicknesses of clean newspaper, on top of the workbench. We dampen the newspaper so they won’t slide around. We sprinkle some water onto the tool, and spread it around with a finger. Then we sprinkle some grit onto the water and tool as if we were liberally salting a dish we were cooking or eating. Then using both hands, we carefully place the mirror face down on top of the tool. We use both hands to make the mirror travel in a circular path in either direction for about 6 turns, grinding the center of the mirror mostly against the edge of the tool. (This needs to be demonstrated!) Wide strokes are good, but the center of the mirror must not get too close to the edge of the tool. At first this motion will be very, very noisy, which is fine. However, after perhaps 20-30 seconds, the noise will decrease. This means that the largest grains of grit have quickly been shattered, and they have also created gouges and fractures in the glass. After a minute or so, you need to separate the mirror and the tool and add some more grit and water, and continue the hogging out. After about 30-40 minutes, it is a good idea to rinse off the mirror, dry it thoroughly, and measure the sagitta with a spherometer to see how much progress you have made. It is a good idea to have a plastic bucket available that you can fill with water and use to rinse off the mirror and tool. The ground-up glass and grit will make a muddy slurry, which will eventually slow down the grinding process.                         essential atm steps grinding

 C. Try not to wrap your hands around the edge of the mirror towards the edge, if at all possible. This will heat up the edge of the mirror, making it expand, which can cause bad, unexpected results.

 D. Systematic rotation is super, super important: develop a method of methodically rotating the mirror and the tool with respect to each other, to the table, and to your body, so that you do not develop astigmatism! There are many ways of doing this. If we had barrels, you would be walking around the barrel. We don’t. We have large, heavy work-benches instead. I like to rotate them both in the same direction, like the hands of a clock, with the top piece of glass going a little faster than the bottom one. Do it systematically, NOT randomly. One way: do about 8 circular strokes. Then center the mirror on the tool. Turn the lower piece of glass to the left by about 15 degrees (1 hour on a normal clock face); then turn the upper piece of glass about 10 more degrees. Then grind away for 8 more circular strokes. Then turn the lower piece of glass to the left by about 15 degrees, and the upper piece by about 10 more degrees. And repeat, again and again. If you have a barrel to walk around, you would do this differently.

 E. It is possible to overshoot your goal when you are doing this initial hogging step. In fact, I recommend overshooting it by perhaps 5 thousandths of an inch, since the hogging stroke does not create a strictly spherical shape. But it does remove a lot of glass very quickly. If you end up much deeper than you intended, then put the mirror on the bottom and the tool on top and continue. Alternating tool on top and mirror on top will allow you to reach you goal as closely as you desire.

 F. Beveling the edge: if you have a sharp edge on your mirror or tool, then you will produce little shards of glass, much like making flint arrowheads. These shards will cut your fingers, and they will also scratch your mirror. Therefore, it is necessary to make sure that the edges of your mirror and your tool (front and back) are beveled or chamfered. There are many ways of doing this. You can use sharpening stones or wet-dry sandpaper, or you can put some water and grit into the wok that one of us banged into a smooth curved shape at his blacksmith shop. However you do it, it doesn’t take too long, and it will prevent lots of problems. You may have to renew the bevel after a while. Keep it around 1/8” (a few millimeters).

[1] If you are interested, I could show you how to derive this formula simply by using the Pythagorean Theorem.

(Link forward to the next section ==>)

(<== Link back to the previous section.)

Part 6 of Leon Foucault’s Article

15 Monday Dec 2014

Posted by gfbrandenburg in History, Telescope Making

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Leon Foucault

Construction details for large telescopes
Setup of eyepieces
Changing power
Mounting the mirror
New wooden equatorial mounting

      After its invention by Newton, the [reflecting] telescope has been redesigned several times by various scholars and artisans. The image formed at the focal point of the mirror in a reflecting telescope does not present itself in a position that is as easy to observe as in a refracting telescope. The various ways that have been devised to make the image of a reflecting telescope more accessible are based on different methods that could be the subject of some debate. From the outset, Newton took the wisest path, which consists of projecting the image out to the side, perpendicular to the axis of the tube, and of observing the image via an eyepiece that is mounted on the exterior of the telescope tube. The cone of the convergent rays of light is reflected by a flat mirror that forms a 45-degree angle with the axis of the tube. The mirror is, of course, located in front of the focal point, at a distance at least as long as the radius of the tube.

.
In order to avoid the losses of light transmission that would be caused by a second metallic reflection, telescope makers have tried to replace the diagonal mirror by a prism with total internal reflection, which would act on the bundle of light rays without causing any other losses except those from absorption in the prism and from partial reflections from the two perpendicular surfaces. However, in large telescopes such a prism would have to grow to such a size that it would be almost impossible to make. In short-focal-length instruments, such as we had in mind, this prism would have to assume even larger dimensions, and would threaten, by its own internal imperfections, to cause all kinds of distortions in the images that would be formed.

.
We chose a different method, in placing a small prism in the path of the light cone, close to the focal point, which would leave the image inside the telescope tube. We then put a composite lens with four elements in the path to bring the image outside the tube and make it visible. Whatever the objections observers might have against lenses composed of four different pieces of glass, one cannot ignore the many advantages of this arrangement. Actually, it solves quite a few problems. First of all, by using a prism only as large as needed to not restrict the field of view, one obtains total internal reflection. Secondly, by being small, it is relatively easy to have a high-quality prism with good internal homogeneity and excellent workmanship on the optical surfaces and their angles. The final advantage is that the four-element lens delivers an upright image.

.
On the other hand, since the composite lens was designed and engineered for refracting telescopes and binoculars, when one links it without modification to short-focus parabolic mirrors, one tends to find a certain amount of spherical aberration. In other words, in this eyepiece, two of the pieces of glass in fact play the role of objective lenses and begin to display the imperfections found with spherical curves. The remedy for this problem is quite simple: one simply performs an additional optical refiguring, which, while sacrificing the mirror image, results in a corrected image vis-a-vis the entire optical system of the mirror and the objective parts of the lens. Using this method, the mirror and the system of amplifying lenses are invariably linked together, and to change the enlargement power of the telescope, one merely has to change the system of the two other lenses, which is similar to the arrangement in an ordinary astronomical eyepiece. Thus, it is no longer actually required to construct mirrors that are exactly parabolic. We feel it is better to end up with an experimental mirror surface, which has purposely the property of acting in concert with the magnifying lenses in the eyepiece, to assure the production of a perfect image.

.
In speaking of the formation of images, the considerations which we have developed have helped us to evaluate the degree of precision required in performing local refiguring of the mirror. These same considerations determine the limits beyond which accidental deformations of the mirror would begin to harm the quality of the images. If we want the images to appear cleanly, it is required that in all the positions held by the mirror, the various elements of the surface must stay fixed among them to a precision of one ten-thousandth of a millimeter, because any relative displacement which exceeds this minimum quantity would place some of the rays of light out of phase with the others, and would throw them out of the effective group. One can understand from this the extreme importance of the precautions to be taken to remove from the mirror all forces that would tend to alter its figure.

.
When the mirror is placed at the end of the tube and the instrument is obliquely directed towards a point in the sky, the weight acts along two perpendicular component vectors, one which tends to compress the mirror in the direction of a diameter seen in a vertical plane, and the other which presses the mirror against the resistant parts that its back rests on. These two components, which vary in a sense contrary to the direction of the instrument, must be combated separately. The one that compresses the mirror on its edge can only by opposed by the rigidity of the material, which, under a given weight, takes on a maximum value when one finishes the back of the mirror with a sufficiently convex form. We have found it advantageous to shape the back of the mirror along a curve such that the thickness doubles from the edge towards the center, where it takes on at least one-tenth of the diameter. This is only a palliative which does not radically prevent deformation, but in reality this component of the weight along a diameter is not too much to be feared, since this deformation diminishes as one raises the telescope towards the zenith, and since the flattening which can occur over the totality of all the convergent ray bundles can be corrected easily by using a cylindrical lens.

.
The other component, whose intensity varies in an inverse manner with the first one, exercises a much more annoying influence on the image. As the instrument is raised up, the solid parts on which the mirror presses make the corresponding parts of the mirror push forwards, and cause undulations which show themselves at the focus via long trails of light. It is necessary to get rid of these local pressures and to spread them out uniformly over the entire surface of the back of the mirror. (To achieve this) we attach to the mirror mount a slab of wood, and we arrange between the two of them a space wherein we slide a circular rubber sac, which will press on the glass once it is inflated. The narrow tube which brings the air into this cushion passes all along the body of the instrument, extends right up to the eyepiece, and ends with a valve. By blowing into the tube with his mouth, the observer can thus, without losing the image in view, regulate at will the pressure and bring it precisely to the point where the mirror floats on its mount, without pressing on either one surface or the other. It is clear that in these conditions, the mirror will escape its own weight as far as the effects of the component which presses entirely on the pneumatic cushion.

.
The regular movement of the instrument will never force the mirror to rock back and forth on its mounting, and the addition of the cushion does not augment this instability of the optical axis which people have complained about telescopes even today. The cushion, which cannot move around as a unit, still continues to modify its surface, under pressure, and reacts distinctly on the clean focus of the image. The frame that holds the mirror, the cylinder, and the pneumatic cushion, is attached to the body of the telescope with pushing and pulling screws (??) which act to regulate the optical axis with respect to the prism and to maintain it in a fixed position.

.
      The body of these new telescopes is made of wood; it has the form of an octagonal tube. Diaphragms that are open and fixed inside at various distances give the system a rigidity which is used when mounting it equatorially. At one third of the way from the mirror we attach two small cylindrical axes (see figure 19) that are mounded perpendicular to the axis of the telescope. Elsewhere, we construct a turntable with two columns, rolling via bearings on a plane that is oriented parallel to the equator and maintained in this position by a little wooden frame. The two columns on the turntable are fitted with babbits to receive the axes of the body of the instrument. Also, the two columns maintain the desired height and separation of the telescope so that it can move freely. The telescope being then put in place, is now mounted equatorially, because its two degrees of freedom are in declination around the little side axes and in right ascension around the axis of the turntable. Prolonged observation of a star requires that the instrument be stopped at a certain declination. For that reason, we attach on the turntable a sort of arm whose end is attached at some point of the telescope by a sliding bar that can be tightened, which forms one variable side of a triangle, and which determines the opening of the opposite angle.

.
A metal disk divided along its circumference and mounted on one of the side axes will serve as a circle of declination, and divisions drawn on the edge of the equatorial platform will serve as the divisions of hours of right ascension. But the positions which they point to will have no more precision than one would need to help find a star which one wants to put into the field of view. This mounting system only constitutes a support mounted in an equatorial manner to aid in observation. The movements are easy, and nothing would prevent one from adding a motor drive if desired.

.
We are currently constructing a similar mount for the 42-centimeter telescope that has been established for several months at the Imperial observatory. [France was then ruled by Emperor Napoleon III – trans.] The mirror was cast at Saint-Gobain, then roughed out and started off at the Sautter and Company factory, which is devoted especially to the construction of light-house lenses. Afterwards, Mr. Sautter has prepared for the future, for much larger disks, and we have received assurances from him of a cooperation which would only fall back if there was a material impossibility. Relieved of a preparation which required special tools and setup, the house of Secretan did all the rest, except for the final refiguring which they did not want to be responsible for. By the intelligent care of Mr. Eichens, who directs the workshops, the mechanical part of the work is perfecting itself so that in a little while we will be in possession of the entire apparatus. {not sure whether he means a complete telescope or a complete workshop – trans.)

.
We are now coming to the conclusion of this series of details, all of which needed to be described, or else we would have left for others the need to discover that which experience had already taught us. We have given those details as information for those who would desire to reproduce the effects which we have obtained. Among the details of execution, there are quite a few that we have obtained in the workshops of Mr. Secretan, and we are pleased to recognize that all of these daily interactions with skilled workmen, intelligent foremen, and a very enlightened head of the operation, have considerably abbreviated our task.

.
Of what did this task consist? We had proposed for ourselves, or rather we had received from the Director of the Observatory, the mission of preparing the way for creating objectives of large dimensions. Would it be necessary to rely on the empirical methods that up until now had been seen as sufficient for the work on glass? What results could we anticipate obtaining in exchange for the increases in expenses? How would we judge that we had succeeded? Could our best instruments up until now still be improved? Could it be that in optics, as in mechanics, there is a maximum of useful effects that would come sooner or later to limit our efforts? All of these questions were implicitly contained in the mission which we received from the Director.

.
In seeking to resolve them, we see now that there was a danger that we might end up going down a path with no way out. Fortunately we took a detour, and leaving refraction aside for the time being, we entrusted to reflection various ways of acting upon light more simply and of correctly forming the focal point where all of the physical theories of light are revealed. Since we only had to deal with a single surface, because of the simple fact of reflection, the experimental line that is folded back upon itself could be contained inside a closed room. Since the point and the image were in proximity to each other, we were able, without leaving a spherical figure, to familiarize ourselves with the methods of acting on glass surfaces, of observing them, and of modifying them based on the demands of optical phenomena. Afterwards applying the same procedures to the cased where the point and the image become farther and farther apart, we have seen the surfaces progressively evolve to various other conic sections, which for a long time have been designated as specially apt for optical uses. Now that this experience has been acquired, we would not hesitate to apply to achromatic objectives a method which has nothing to fear from the analytical complication of surfaces. Nonetheless, these glass mirrors, which were merely accessories, have lent to the silvering process such a remarkable metallic shine, that now they rival objective lenses of the same size.

.
Without losing sight of the main object of this work, which was to furnish practical results, we have been led in our work to recognize the weaknesses of the purely geometrical approach on which the theory of optical instruments was formerly based. All of the facts we have observed condemn any system in which one takes no account of the periodic nature of light, and wherein one neglects the principal element which comes into play in the mechanics of the formation of images. On the contrary, the facts show that at the focal point of surfaces that precise enough to display the intimate details of light, the rays obey the fundamental principle of interference. The latter results justify a doctrine that the human spirit has given itself as a guide and which appears to embrace the entire universe of phenomena of optical physics.

<THE END>

← Older posts
Newer posts →

Subscribe

  • Entries (RSS)
  • Comments (RSS)

Archives

  • October 2026
  • September 2026
  • August 2026
  • July 2026
  • June 2026
  • May 2026
  • April 2026
  • February 2026
  • December 2025
  • November 2025
  • October 2025
  • September 2025
  • July 2025
  • January 2025
  • November 2024
  • October 2024
  • August 2024
  • July 2024
  • May 2024
  • April 2024
  • January 2024
  • December 2023
  • October 2023
  • August 2023
  • June 2023
  • May 2023
  • April 2023
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • May 2021
  • March 2021
  • December 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • January 2019
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • May 2018
  • March 2018
  • January 2018
  • November 2017
  • October 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • February 2017
  • December 2016
  • September 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016
  • December 2015
  • November 2015
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • April 2015
  • March 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • December 2014

Categories

  • astronomy
  • astrophysics
  • education
  • flat
  • History
  • Hopewell Observatorry
  • Math
  • monochromatic
  • nature
  • optical flat
  • Optics
  • Safety
  • science
  • teaching
  • Telescope Making
  • Uncategorized

Meta

  • Create account
  • Log in

Blog at WordPress.com.

  • Subscribe Subscribed
    Guy's Math & Astro Blog
    Join 52 other subscribers

    Have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.

  • Guy's Math & Astro Blog
    View site in Reader
    Manage subscriptionsSign upLog in
    Report this content
    Collapse this bar
Loading Comments...